🍕

Best Pizza on Long Island 2026

Pizza is a battleground on Long Island — cast your vote and decide who takes the crown this year.

4,231 votes cast • Voting ends March 1, 2026

1

Umberto's of New Hyde Park

📍 New Hyde Park

28%

2

Gino's Pizzeria of Commack

📍 Commack

22%

3

King Umberto

📍 Elmont

18%

4

Grandpa Tony's

📍 Bethpage

14%

5

Villaggio Brick Oven Pizza

📍 Massapequa

10%

6

Luigi's Pizza

📍 Huntington

8%

🎉

Vote Submitted!

Thanks for voting! Your voice helps decide Long Island's best pizza. Want to see live results?

Become a LIT Insider

← Vote in more categories